Book Review: Downfall of the Templars: Guilty of Diabolic Magic?
Downfall of the Templars is a gripping and thoroughly researched examination of one of the most dramatic betrayals in medieval history. Tony McMahon combines vivid storytelling with meticulous scholarship to provide a compelling account of how the Knights Templar – once revered heroes of Christendom – were suddenly recast as heretics, sorcerers, and traitors. The result is an engaging narrative that reads as much like a historical thriller as it does a work of non-fiction.
McMahon excels in presenting the extraordinary contradictions at the heart of the Templars’ story. For two centuries they had been the poster boys of crusading virtue: spartan warrior-monks, bankers to kings, and stalwart defenders of the Holy Land . Yet in 1307 they were rounded up in mass dawn raids across France, accused of denying Christ, spitting on the crucifix, obscene initiation rites, sodomy, and even worshipping a mysterious demonic head known as Baphomet . McMahon shows how these shocking accusations reflected a wider medieval fusion of heresy and sorcery – the early rumblings of the witchcraft mania that would later sweep Europe.
One of the most fascinating aspects of the book is its portrayal of King Philip IV of France, whose paranoia and belief in widespread occult conspiracies drove not only the assault on the Templars but also parallel prosecutions of bishops, mystics, and even a dead pope accused of consorting with the devil . The case of Bishop Guichard – accused of murdering the queen using wax dolls and poison brewed with scorpions and spiders – is just one of many astonishing episodes woven into the narrative .
McMahon also shows how Pope Clement V, often portrayed as Philip’s puppet, was in reality caught in an impossible position. The rediscovery of the Chinon Parchment – included in the book’s research – reveals that Clement actually absolved the Templar leadership of heresy, even if he ultimately lacked the power to save the order from destruction .
Beyond the politics, the book explores the myths that followed the Templars: their supposed hidden treasure, flights to Scotland and Portugal, and the later emergence of neo-Templar movements and conspiracy lore. Chapters on the Priory of Sion and the Templars’ influence on modern culture – from Star Wars to Assassin’s Creed – add a refreshing contemporary dimension .
Overall, Downfall of the Templars is a rich, lively, and thought-provoking work that brings new clarity to an endlessly intriguing chapter of history. It is highly recommended for readers of medieval history, mystery enthusiasts, and anyone captivated by the enduring legend of the Knights Templar.
< BACK